70 West Madison Street, Suite 1500, Chicago, Illinois 60602

blog-hero

Patent

Smoke Gets in Your Pipe

April 1st, 2025

gct

Here’s What Happened: Healthier Choices Management Corp is a grocery and vape store chain. Healthier Choices applied to patent its own electronic vaping pipe. Philip Morris also had a line of electronic vaping pipes. In an interparty proceeding before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, Philip Morris challenged Healthier Choices’ patent. The Board agreed with […]


Gambling with an Abstract Idea

June 30th, 2024

gct

Here’s What Happened: Beteiro LLC owns four patents that share a common specification and title “Apparatus and Method for Facilitating Gaming Activity and/or Gambling Activity.” Each of the patents facilitated remote gambling activity. The patent examiner determined that the software had the needed specific machine or processor, namely a GPS system, to be patented. Beteiro […]


Enabling Inventors

April 3rd, 2024

gct

In Brief:  Inventorship can be based on unclaimed improvements that are necessary for enabling the invention to work.  Here’s What Happened:   Steve Campbell invented a container for transporting gaseous fluids consisting of an insulated housing, pressure vessels and port bosses. But his prototypes suffered from numerous problems, including slippage of the port boss on […]


Timekeeping is the Same Whether by Quill or Computer

February 7th, 2024

gct

In Brief:   Abstract ideas for time tracking software are not patentable. Here’s What Happened:   Realtime Tracker Inc. holds a patent for “Realtime Billable Timekeeper Method, System and Apparatus,” which it described as a “novel computer system, operation and function” for tracking billable hours for professionals in client service fields. Realtime brought suit against RELX, […]


Patent Inventors are Coiled Together

December 14th, 2023

gct

In Brief:  Joint inventorship can be based on designs disclosed during an investment pitch. Here’s What Happened:   Gary Ragner designed a hose and assigned the invention to his company, Ragner Technology Corp. In 2011, Ragner was looking for investors to bring its MicroHose product to market. Gary met with Michael Berardi, who had a […]


Bringing Home the Patent Bacon

July 26th, 2023

gct

In Brief:  A named inventor has to make a significant contribution to the claims in a patent. Here’s What Happened: Hormel Foods Corporation obtained a patent for a two-step process for precooking bacon and meat pieces. The first step involves preheating in a microwave oven and the second step involves cooking the meat in a […]


Patented Stylist Has a Wardrobe Malfunction

April 25th, 2023

gct

In Brief:   Automating how to choose an outfit is not patentable subject matter. Here’s What Happened: Stylitics, Inc.’s is an e-commerce platform that allows its commercial website clients to create aggregated shoppable content. Stylitics’ “Auto-Styler” creates collages of merchandise. It automatically generates a plurality of outfits that conform to one or more styles. It gives […]


Stop in the Name of a Patent Assignment

March 14th, 2023

gct

In Brief: An inventor can’t claim their invention is invalid after an assignment. Here’s What Happened: Csaba Truckai was one of the named inventors of a device used to treat vaginal bleeding. He and his fellow inventors founded a company called NovaCept, Inc. Csaba and his fellow inventors applied for a patent and then assigned […]


© 2026 Golan Christie Taglia. All Rights Reserved.